In the final two pages of Amusing
Ourselves to Death, Neil Postman reveals his belief that the only way to
save our society from transforming into the Huxleyan civilization of Brave New World is for
schools to raise media consciousness and discover how to control television.
These were Postman's hopes for the future, our present. However,
doesn't television still control education?
Our education is still conducted using language based on the structure of dialogue on television: short and sweet. We don’t
speak as the people did 150 years ago when typography was the main form of
public discourse. "Educational" shows like "Sesame Street"
still exist and continue to attract kids to television, providing entertainment
instead of education. Even "educational" movies and clips shown
in class as visual aids, like Swing
Kids, are forms of entertainment. For example, in the many
classes other students and I have taken, we are shown video clips that many
consider to be boring; however, despite this fact, we are always excited by the
prospect of watching a video. Why? We have been brought up to love
television and the entertainment that it brings. In addition, nothing in
school (besides these novels) has made me more "media conscious" and
aware of the negative effects of television. If anything, aren’t schools
advocating the use of television? Many students are assigned homework that requires
them to watch television shows. For
example, in my Spanish class last year, we were required to watch Spanish
television shows and write reports on what we saw and understood. Although this may seem to be an educational
tool, isn’t this really just attracting kids to television and entertainment,
further warping their perceptions of truth and knowledge? Television continues to feed America irrelevant,
trivial information, turning serious forms of public discourse into forms of
entertainment.
Television isn't the only
medium of discourse either. Isn't the use of the Internet also being
emphasized by schools? Throughout middle and high school, students are
being pushed to use the Internet to find information and submit assignments. Postman
hoped that schools would help distance society from these mediums of discourse;
however, haven’t schools only succeeded in further establishing a niche for
them in society?
What do you think? Are we doomed to transform into a
Huxleyan world? Is there a way to counter the influence of television,
and now, the Internet? Can you think of any other solutions to
"save" our society from the negative impacts of the media?
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.