A main idea Carr discusses in The Shallows is the negative impact Google may have on our society. He proposes two questions: Is Google "dumbing us down"? Is Google doing the opposite of what it was meant to
do? I personally feel that maybe this negative perception towards the internet may just be our paranoia. I know it sounds brain-washed, but look
around. Have we stopped all research? Have we given up advancing technology, have we
sat down satisfied with where we are now? Not even close. In fact, the race to
the future is more pressured than ever, as we tell ourselves how unsatisfied we
are with what we have. How many times have you heard, “Nah, I won’t buy the
IPhone 4, I’ll just wait for the newer version, it should be out soon”. People want the next best thing, and there a lot of people out there willing to find it. We’re increasing our knowledge every minute, trying
to satisfy buyer needs, fix medical problems, be the first to live on Mars,
etc. I really don't think Google is "dumbing us down". Look at everyone on this blog. We’re taking
college courses, learning things ahead of our level. There’s a good amount of
us who want to go into the math and science field, research life, chemistry,
computers. Carr says himself , “I can’t keep track of the hours Google has saved
me”. Remember when we learned that
scientists have to record their data, so the next person can refer to it and
improve it. Well, the internet is recording our data, and we’re the next
generation. Google’s just our bottom base, holding basic knowledge, and we’re
here to build on it with discoveries. What do you think, is Google a friend or a foe?
That is a great point you make, Yasmine, about how we are recording data for the next generation. Even though Google spares me so much time all day everyday, I don't know if it actually making us smarter. For, how many times have our teachers told us to not use Wikipedia for a research papter, or to make sure the websites we rely on are ".edu or .org " only. How reliable is the information we receive ? Is it even true information ?
ReplyDeleteThanks Alexa. Yes, we can get some unreliable websites and information, but it's really not that hard to find accurate answers. As for Wikipedia, the website clearly states that anyone can edit it and that the information is "imperfect". If you want to make sure you're accurate, there is a warning there for you. Google is the door to the information, its our own responsibility to make sure we only believe accuracy.
Delete